Talk:Aine Yūki/@comment-31978949-20180126032246/@comment-27209645-20180126122656

Well, to be fair (i'm saying this as someone who's not fond of Yume btw) I don't think Yume is objectively bad. The reason why Ichigo got away with it was because she's the first protagonist and we didn't have anyone to compare her to also people seem to really like her for some reason (I bet it's mostly because of nostalgia though). Sometimes it's not just about losing or winning but it also come to execution: the role of the writers is to create a plotline and make us believe that what's happening is actually logical. And that's where Aikatsu stars fails: I rarely got the impression that Yume deserved to win. Do you guys even remember all the first season nonsense that happend? For example, there was an episode where Rola had to perform with Hime but she couldn't make it because she was filming a commercial. All that set up was just to make Yume perform with Hime despite her loss. Even when Yume lost against someone she still got the best end of the stick while the others didn't. What point is there to lose if the plot will make your loss not matter? Either way Yume still performed with Hime.

Also taking away all the win/lose plot, i just didn't find Yume all that great. Don't get me wrong: she's cute, she's nice, she's truthful. And that's the problem. I honestly don't remember much of her despite the fact that she's the MC. Basically: It doesn't matter how kind the character is if you can't make me care for her. To this day her best arc was when she was sad of losing Koharu. And that's about what i remember.