Talk:Jeweling Dress/@comment-39369359-20190711165042

I don't see why we couldn't have the Jeweling Dresses be in a set of the 12 birthstones. It would have run with the trend of the "fantastic, mysterious dresses" in the Aikatsu series coming in sets of 12. 12 constellations, 9 planets plus Hime's Moon Dress and Elza and Yume's Sun Dresses. The zodiac signs of the Aikatsu S2 girls even corresponded to their dresses. Well, if we went that route, then Aine would have Ruby, Mio would have Garnet, Maika would have Peridot, Ema would have Aquamarine, the Shirayuri twins would both have Pearl, Karen would have Tourmaline, Mirai and Hibiki would have Emerald, Alicia would have Amethyst, and Wakaba would have Sapphire. This is clearly a mess, as November, December, and April (with the ever-so-important Diamond Dress) are left completely unrepresented. Mirai and Hibiki are born in the same month, and the Baby Pirates (the only eligible idols to fill the empty spots) don't actually have birthdays.

It totally would have worked out if Aine was born in April, Mio in September, Maika in February, Ema in November, Alicia in May, Hibiki in July, Mirai in January, Karen in October, and Wakaba in August. I don't think that it would be much of a problem is the Shirayuri twins were still born in June, because then they could do the Gemini thing and have 2 brands collaborate on one Jewel. And to complete the calender, Marin would be born in March for Aquamarine, and Rinna would be born in December for Tanzanite. Like, seriously. Everyone gets a dress, all of the fans are happy.